I said we had a good OL, did I not? We didn't have the best, and the stats back that up.
Seeing how that wasn't even the point of your OP, are you sure AT would have taken carries away from Jwill or Collins? Are you sure he's even on the same level? I'm not saying you're wrong or that he's not, but these blind assumptions by some people are just that....assumptions, not facts.
I may be wayyyyy off base or not know all of the details, but it just seems to me that if AT was that much of a can't miss talent that surely a Pac12, Big10, or Big12 school would have rolled the dice on him. It's not like he had the same character issues as Dyer. The REALITY of the situation is that what we see on the surface is that AT was a 4* RB that couldn't get playing time against other 4 or 5*s at Bama, but he's good enough to come in and beat out our 4*s? Like you said, sometimes *s lie. We won't know about AT til he finishes his college career, but I think there's plenty of reason to at least have doubts, isn't there?
Also keep in mind that 2 players ahead of him on the depth chart went down this last season, and he STILL didn't get reps....and let's also not pretend that Bama's OL is garbage or something.